The Top Influencer Marketing Mistakes (And How to Fix Them)

Influencer marketing: everyone's doing it! It's the fast track to building a loyal fanbase and getting your brand seen. Plus, content creators do half the work for you! 

But, let's be real, it's not all sunshine and rainbows. There are some serious pitfalls, especially if you're new to the game. With social media changing faster than your phone's software, it's easy to get lost. 

Don't worry, we've got you covered. Here are the top 5 influencer marketing errors and how to avoid them.

1. Picking the Wrong Influencer → It's Not Just About the Numbers

Millions of followers? Sounds like a win… Not necessarily! It's not just about numbers. You've got to dig deeper. Check their upload schedule, consistency, and, most importantly, if they match the vibe of your brand. While authenticity is king, brand alignment still matters. 

Think of it this way: it's not just about matching industries, it's about matching values. 

You need to ensure your influencer's content resonates with your target audience and reflects your brand's personality.

  • Do your homework: Research potential influencers thoroughly. Don't just look at their follower count. Analyze their engagement rates, content quality, and audience demographics. Use tools to see if their followers are real and active.
  • Know your audience: Analyze their audience demographics and interests. Are their followers the kind of people who would be interested in your product or service? Do their interests align with your brand?
  • Match your values: Ensure their content and values align with your brand. If your brand is eco-friendly, partnering with an influencer who promotes fast fashion would be a major disconnect.

2. Ignoring Authenticity → Real Talk Wins

Let's face it, social media has become the Wild West. Brand safety? That's long gone. Now, it's all about authenticity. 

Opinionated, outspoken influencers? They're your best bet. They're honest, and their audience trusts them. If they love your brand, their fans will too. Audiences can spot a fake endorsement a mile away.

  • Give them freedom: Allow influencers creative freedom to create content in their own style. Don't try to force them into a rigid script or format. Let them use their own voice and creativity.
  • Find true believers: Partner with influencers who genuinely believe in your brand. If they're passionate about your product or service, it will come across in their content.
  • Be transparent: Prioritize transparency and disclosure of sponsored content. Audiences appreciate honesty and are more likely to trust influencers who are upfront about their partnerships.

3. Neglecting Due Diligence → Vetting Your Influencers

You are putting your brand's reputation in someone else's hands, so do your due diligence. Big creators can get caught up in drama or scandals, and that reflects on you. You need to be sure that your influencers are reliable and trustworthy.

  • Check for real followers: Use tools to analyze follower growth and engagement. Look for suspicious patterns that might indicate purchased followers.
  • Review their history: Look at their past content and social media activity. Are there any red flags? Have they been involved in any controversies?
  • Make sure they are clean: Ensure they haven't engaged in any behavior that could damage your brand's reputation. This includes things like hate speech, illegal activities, or unethical behavior.

4. Rigid Briefings → Giving Them the Right Tools

Even the best influencer can't sell a dud product or a vague idea. Give them a clear product description and key talking points, then let them work their magic. That's how you get ads that don't feel like ads. 

The influencer should have a deep understanding of your product and the freedom to show it to their audience in a way that feels natural.

  • Give them the product: Provide the influencer with ample opportunity to experience and understand the product. Let them use it, test it, and form their own opinions.
  • Let them be themselves: Encourage influencers to create content that feels natural and aligns with their style. Don't try to micromanage them or dictate every detail.
  • Keep it real: Avoid overly scripted or promotional content. Audiences can tell when an ad is forced or inauthentic. Focus on creating content that is engaging and informative.

5. Forgetting the Long Game → Building Lasting Relationships

Influencer marketing isn't a one-night stand. Build relationships! Open communication and transparency are key. Think long-term, like creating a continuous brand story. For example, for a game launch, work with influencers throughout the development process, during early access, and after launch. This creates a long-running narrative that feels authentic.

  • Open Communication: Maintain open and consistent communication with your influencers. Be responsive to their questions and feedback.
  • Long-Term Strategy: Develop a long-term influencer marketing strategy. Don't just focus on short-term campaigns.
  • Brand Storytelling: Collaborate with influencers to build a continuous brand story. This can involve creating content that follows a narrative arc or that explores different aspects of your brand over time.

Wrapping it up:

Influencer marketing is a powerful tool, but it's easy to get it wrong. By avoiding these common mistakes, you'll be well on your way to building a successful campaign. Remember, it's about building genuine connections with both influencers and their audiences. Now, go out there and reach your audience where it matters!

More blog posts like this

Ready to transform your brand with optimized influencer marketing? Contact Audiencly today for a tailored strategy that drives results.

Submit a request, and we will get in touch with you within the day to provide consultation on all matters.

Write us

You're awesome!

Your message was sent successfully. Expect a confirmation email in your inbox soon. Thanks for reaching out!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Make Appointment
Make Appointment

Dan and Phil Games

TD Bricks

The Act Man

Socksfor1

Dan and Phil Games